New Buffalo Market Report
$967,661
AVERAGE PRICE OF 135 HOMES$2,193,513
AVERAGE PRICE OF 38 MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR HOMES$1,242,822
AVERAGE PRICE OF 9 NEWLY BUILT HOMES$1,690,500
AVERAGE PRICE OF 15 HOMES WITH A POOL$617,881
AVERAGE PRICE OF 11 REDUCED PRICE HOMESAverage Home
| Average Price | $967,661 |
| Avg Bedrooms | 2.34 beds |
| Avg Bathrooms | 1.98 baths |
Average Price by Bedrooms
| 1 bedroom | $424,000 |
| 2 bedrooms | $507,487 |
| 3 bedrooms | $1,055,632 |
| 4 bedrooms | $1,379,821 |
| 5 bedrooms | $1,252,625 |
New Buffalo Home Price Trends
| 5/2025 | 4/2025 | 3/2025 | 2/2025 | 1/2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total Listings | 122 | 111 | 102 | 99 | 91 |
| Average Price | $1,008,506 | $1,016,373 | $1,008,173 | $948,912 | $908,163 |
| Avg Price Change | -0.78% | +0.81% | +6.25% | +4.49% | +0.17% |
| Median Price | $685,083 | $677,029 | $693,235 | $609,299 | $588,431 |
| Med Price Change | +1.19% | -2.39% | +13.78% | +3.55% | -1.23% |
| Avg Bedrooms | 2.27 beds | 2.11 beds | 2.1 beds | 1.86 beds | 1.82 beds |
| Avg Bathrooms | 1.94 baths | 1.81 baths | 1.83 baths | 1.71 baths | 1.68 baths |
Home Price by High School
| School Name | Total Homes | Average Price | Avg Days on Site |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Buffalo Senior High School | 23 | $799,391 | 87 days |
| Total Homes | Average Price | Avg Days on Site | |
|---|---|---|---|
| All Homes | 135 | $967,661 | 121 days |
| Multi-Million Dollar Homes | 38 | $2,193,513 | 105 days |
| Newly Built Homes | 9 | $1,242,822 | 100 days |
| Homes with a Pool | 15 | $1,690,500 | 92 days |
| Reduced Price Homes | 11 | $617,881 | 51 days |
